Should I stick with the old, beat-up “character” of the existing plinth blocks and just clean them up, or should I reproduce them?

The existing blocks had been accumulating paint and dings for 120 years. Although the paint can be removed rather easily with a heat gun and the dings can be filled with wood filler, I opted for the reproduction route. Reproducing the blocks allowed me to regain crisp, sharp edges compared to the worn and broken edges of the older blocks. I also had a closet doorway that lacked plinth blocks, and creating new ones meant I could add them.

Existing plinth block
Existing plinth block

I started by ripping a 5/4 plank of Douglas fir down to the 5” width I needed for the plinth blocks and cut as many blocks as possible to the correct height.

Cut to width
Cut to width

Using the best looking block from my existing set, I traced the profile onto the edge of each new block.

Trace the profile
Trace the profile

This was my first use of the band saw, so I cut along the pencil lines, but left plenty of room for mistakes.

Cut a rough profile
Cut a rough profile
Continue the rough profile
Continue the rough profile
Rough cut profile
Rough cut profile
Repeat as needed
Repeat as needed

Once the blocks were cut, I sanded the profile down to the pencil lines. A few cuts slipped into the final profile as I got too close to the pencil line and it required a bit of wood filler. Unfortunately, you can still see those lines in the finished product, but they are a vast improvement over the appearance of the old blocks.

Painted and installed
Painted and installed